Changes

| [[White LabsEscarpment Laboratories]] || WLP677 Lactobacillus Blend || L. delbrueckii (potentially misidentified) brevis and L. plantarum || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner">[http://www.milkthefunk.com/wiki/100%25_Lactobacillus_Fermentation Milk The Funk Wiki. 100% Lactobacillus Fermentation Test by Lance Shaner.]</ref><ref name="tmf_cultures">[http://www.themadfermentationist.com/p/commercial-cultures.html ''Commercial Brettanomyces, Lactobacillus, and Pediococcus Descriptions''. The Mad Fermentationist Blog. Michael Tonsmeire. Retrieved 3/4/2015.]</ref> || no stir plate, room temp ||Incubate This blend is designed to be usable at > 90°F and < 117°F for 5-7 days for greater lactic acid production. Cell count: 50-80 million cells/mL (1.75-2.8 billion cells in a 35 mL homebrew vial) <ref name="WL_cellcounts">Private correspondence with White Labs Customer Service wide range of temperatures, and Dan Pixley. 10/29/2015.</ref>. Not a good strain is especially suited for kettle souring, but can produce a "soft" acidity over a longer period of time <ref>[https://wwwsour worting.facebookWe recommend pre-acidifying wort to 4.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1212455192116026/?comment_id=1212475888780623&reply_comment_id=1212476575447221&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R3%22%7D Conversation 5 with Andrew Addkison on MTF. 01/12/2016.]</ref>. White Labs claims that it is tolerant to up to 20 IBU <ref>[http://www.themadfermentationist.com/p/commercial-cultures.html "Commercial Brettanomyceslactic acid, then pitching the Lactobacillus, and Pediococcus Descriptions; Commercial Yeast Laboratories." The Mad Fermentationist blog. Michael Tonsmeire. Retrieved 12/12/2016.]</ref>blend in a CO2-purged kettle or fermentor at 32-42°C.

| [[White LabsEscarpment Laboratories]] || WLP672 Lactobacillus brevis || L. brevis || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref><ref name="nick">[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1029638267064387/?comment_id=1030638553631025&offset=0&total_comments=24 Conversation with Nick Impellitteri from The Yeast Bay on the MTF Facebook Group. 3/4/2015.]</ref> || No stir plate, room temp|| Produced by [[The Yeast Bay]]. More This strain is moderately hop -tolerant than other Lacto strains, however TYB advises to use wort with less than 10 IBU. Temperature range: 70and as such it can also be used for long-95°F; 80% attenuation (this may not reflect actual attenuation term souring of wort in a real brewery; see reference <ref>[https://www10IBU beers.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1031115430250004/?comment_id=1031244193570461&offset=0&total_comments=33 Conversation with Michael Soo and Nick Impellitteri on the Milk The Funk Facebook Group. 3/5/2015.]</ref>). <ref>[http://www.theyeastbay.comIt also performs well in kettle souring/wild-yeast-sour worting where fast and-bacteria-products/wlp672-lactobacillus-brevis The Yeast Bay website. Retrieved 3/2/2015clean lactic acidity is desired.]</ref> Cell count: 50We recommend pre-80 million cells/mL (1acidifying wort to 4.755 with lactic acid, then pitching the Lactobacillus blend in a CO2-2.8 billion cells for purged kettle or fermentor at 35 mL homebrew vials) <ref name="WL_cellcounts"></ref>-45°C.

| [[WyeastInland Island Brewing & Consulting|Inland Island Yeast Laboratories]] || 5335 INISBC-991 || L. buchneri brevis || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref> || 1 liter starter for a 5 gallon batch of beer, 1|| Produces more lactic acid at higher temperatures and in low hop worts.020 DME sterile wort, no stir plate, no O2, starter at 90°F if possible 570-95 F Temperature Range|-7 days | [[Inland Island Brewing & Consulting|Inland Island Yeast Laboratories]] | Incubate at 90°F for 5| INISBC-7 days for greater 992 || L. delbruekii || Homofermentative || || Produces more lactic acid production. Cell count: 1.0 x 10⁸ (100 million) cells/mL (10 billion cells at higher temperatures and in a 100 mL homebrew pouch) <ref name="wyeast_cellcounts">[https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0B8CshC9nxYHdZmE4MmoyLXA2WVk&usp=sharing Wyeast Specifications 2015 Retail Products. 2015.]</ref>low hop worts. 70-95 F Temperature Range

| [[Wyeast]] || 5223-PC || L. brevis Inland Island Brewing & Consulting|| Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref><ref name="nick"></ref> || no stir plate, room temp is fine || Heterofermentative (produces lactic acid, ethanol and CO2), more hop tolerant. Does well at room temperature. AVAILABLE ONLY FROM JULY THROUGH SEPTEMBER 2014 (Michael Dawson from Wyeast indicated that this culture may return at some point). Jamie Daly indicated on MTF that he got almost no sourness after 24 hours at 100°F (37.8°C). He lowered the temperature to 90°F-95°F (32.2°C-35°C) for 36 hours, and the pH of the wort went down to 3.29. Thus, Jamie recommends 90°F-95°F (32.2°C-35°C) for 60 hours for better souring; avoid warmer temperatures. He also aerated his starter of L. brevis (2L starter of 1.020 DME) and set it on a stir plate at 95°F <ref name="brevis_aeration">[http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC547135/ Growth Response of Lactobacillus brevis to Aeration and Organic Catalysts. J. R. Stamer and B. O. Stoyla. Appl Microbiol. Sep 1967; 15(5): 1025–1030.]</ref>. The beer wort was not aerated, and the fermenter was flushed with CO2. These methods need verification. Cell count: 1.0 x 10⁸ (100 million) cells/mL (10 billion cells in a 100 mL homebrew pouch) <ref name="wyeast_cellcounts"></ref>.|-| [[Omega Inland Island Yeast LabsLaboratories]] || OYLINISBC-605 932 || L. brevis, <span style="text-decoration: line-through;">delbrueckii</span>, and plantarum blend fermentum || Hetero/Hetero <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref> Heterofermentative || 1 liter starter for a 5 gallon batch of beer at room temperature for 24-48 hours. No stir plate unless kept anaerobic. || Quick souring. Pitch into 65°F-95°F <ref name="adi_oyl605"></ref>. Holding temperature is not required. No longer contains delbruekii <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1065268213501392/?comment_id=1065669443461269&offset=0&total_comments=18&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D Conversation with Raymond Wagner of Oso Brewing Co on Milk The Funk. 4/30/2015.]</ref>. Don't use any hops if possible. 2 IBU is a good target if hops must be used <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1092523807442499/?comment_id=1092571350771078&offset=0&total_comments=6&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R1%22%7D Conversation with Lance Shaner on MTF in regards to IBU tolerance of OYL-605. 6/15/2015.]</ref>. Contains ~150 billion cells per homebrew pitch <ref name="sbb2.0">[http://sourbeerblog.com/lactobacillus-2-0-advanced-techniques-for-fast-souring-beer/ Lactobacillus 2.0 – Advanced Techniques for Fast Souring Beer. Sour Beer Blog. Matt Miller. 11/18/2015. Retrieved 11/19/2015.]</ref>.

| [[Inland Island Brewing & Consulting|Inland Island The Yeast LaboratoriesBay]] || INISBC-991 Lactobacillus Blend || L. plantarum, L. brevis , and an unidentified ''Lactobacillus'' species || Heterofermentative || || Produces more lactic acid at higher The Lactobacillus Blend includes three strains: Lactobacillus plantarum, Lactobacillus brevis and a strain of Lactobacillus isolated from a very unique brewer of American sour beers the returned a sequencing result of "uncultured Lactobacillus". Sure to please anyone with a knack for creating sour beers, it can quickly produce acidity across a wide range of temperatures . This blend can be used on its own for kettle souring prior to pitching yeast to create acidity quickly, or co-pitched with yeast to create sourness over time. It will produce a pronounced and rounded acidity that is the foundation of any complex sour beer. We recommend holding the IBU on the low end (< 2-3) if you'd like to use this blend to create acidity in low hop wortsa shorter time frame. Higher IBUs may result in very slow or no souring (testing is still ongoing to determine IBU at which lactic acid production is inhibited). Temperature: 70-90°F. Cell count: 50-80 million cells/mL (1.75-2.8 billion cells for 35 mL homebrew vials) <ref name="WL_cellcounts"></ref><ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1280135442014667/?comment_id=1280341068660771&reply_comment_id=1280498695311675&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R1%22%7D Conversation with Nick Impellitteri on MTF regarding TYB Lactobacillus Blend cell counts. 04/08/2016.]</ref>. Recommended temperature range for fastest acid production for kettle souring is 85-90°F, although if kept in the 70's it should produce good acidification in 48-95 F Temperature Range72 hours. A major drop off of in acid production is seen above 90°F <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1616265398401668/?comment_id=1617001948328013&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D Impellitteri, Nick. Milk The Funk Facebook group. 03/17/2017.]</ref>.|- | [[Inland Island Brewing & Consulting|Inland Island Yeast LaboratoriesWhite Labs]] || INISBC-992 WLP677 || L. delbruekii delbrueckii (potentially misidentified) || Homofermentative Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner">[http://www.milkthefunk.com/wiki/100%25_Lactobacillus_Fermentation Milk The Funk Wiki. 100% Lactobacillus Fermentation Test by Lance Shaner.]</ref><ref name="tmf_cultures">[http://www.themadfermentationist.com/p/commercial-cultures.html ''Commercial Brettanomyces, Lactobacillus, and Pediococcus Descriptions''. The Mad Fermentationist Blog. Michael Tonsmeire. Retrieved 3/4/2015.]</ref> || no stir plate, room temp || Produces more Incubate at > 90°F and < 117°F for 5-7 days for greater lactic acid production. Cell count: 50-80 million cells/mL (1.75-2.8 billion cells in a 35 mL homebrew vial) <ref name="WL_cellcounts">Private correspondence with White Labs Customer Service and Dan Pixley. 10/29/2015.</ref>. Not a good strain for kettle souring, but can produce a "soft" acidity over a longer period of time <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1212455192116026/?comment_id=1212475888780623&reply_comment_id=1212476575447221&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R3%22%7D Conversation with Andrew Addkison on MTF. 01/12/2016.]</ref>. White Labs claims that it is tolerant to up to 20 IBU, although growth starts to become inhibited at higher temperatures 15 IBU <ref name="WL_datasheet" /><ref>[http://www.themadfermentationist.com/p/commercial-cultures.html "Commercial Brettanomyces, Lactobacillus, and in low hop wortsPediococcus Descriptions; Commercial Yeast Laboratories." The Mad Fermentationist blog. Michael Tonsmeire. Retrieved 12/12/2016.]</ref>. 70Generally heat tolerant, but sours faster between 100-95 F Temperature Range110°F <ref name="WL_datasheet">[www.whitelabs.com/sites/default/files/R%26D%20Wild%20Yeast%20and%20Bacteria%20Experiments_2.pdf "R&D Wild Yeast and Bacteria Experiments". White Labs data sheet. Retrieved 05/16/2017.]</ref>

| [[Inland Island Brewing & Consulting|Inland Island Yeast LaboratoriesWhite Labs]] || INISBC-932 WLP672 || L. fermentum brevis || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref><ref name="nick">[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1029638267064387/?comment_id=1030638553631025&offset=0&total_comments=24 Conversation with Nick Impellitteri from The Yeast Bay on the MTF Facebook Group. 3/4/2015.]</ref> || No stir plate, room temp|| Produced by [[The Yeast Bay]]. More hop tolerant than other Lacto strains, however TYB advises to use wort with less than 10 IBU. White Labs data sheet shows that growth is inhibited to 82% at 5 IBU, and 60% at 10 IBU <ref name="WL_datasheet" />. Temperature range: 70-95°F (greatly inhibited at 110°F) <ref name="WL_datasheet" />; 80% attenuation (this may not reflect actual attenuation of wort in a real brewery; see reference <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1031115430250004/?comment_id=1031244193570461&offset=0&total_comments=33 Conversation with Michael Soo and Nick Impellitteri on the Milk The Funk Facebook Group. 3/5/2015.]</ref>). <ref>[http://www.theyeastbay.com/wild-yeast-and-bacteria-products/wlp672-lactobacillus-brevis The Yeast Bay website. Retrieved 3/2/2015.]</ref> Cell count: 50-80 million cells/mL (1.75-2.8 billion cells for 35 mL homebrew vials) <ref name="WL_cellcounts"></ref>.

| [[Escarpment LaboratoriesWyeast]] || Lactobacillus Blend 5335 || L. brevis and L. plantarum buchneri || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref> || || This blend is designed to be usable at 1 liter starter for a wide range 5 gallon batch of temperaturesbeer, and is especially suited for kettle souring/sour worting1. We recommend pre020 DME sterile wort, no stir plate, no O2, starter at 90°F if possible 5-acidifying wort to 4.7 days || Incubate at 90°F for 5 with -7 days for greater lactic acid, then pitching the Lactobacillus blend production. Cell count: 1.0 x 10⁸ (100 million) cells/mL (10 billion cells in a CO2-purged kettle or fermentor at 32-42°C100 mL homebrew pouch) <ref name="wyeast_cellcounts">[https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0B8CshC9nxYHdZmE4MmoyLXA2WVk&usp=sharing Wyeast Specifications 2015 Retail Products. 2015.]</ref>.

| [[Escarpment LaboratoriesWyeast]] || Lactobacillus brevis 5223-PC || L. brevis || Heterofermentative <ref name="mtf_wiki_shaner"></ref><ref name="nick"></ref> || no stir plate, room temp is fine || This strain is moderately Heterofermentative (produces lactic acid, ethanol and CO2), more hoptolerant. Does well at room temperature. AVAILABLE ONLY FROM JULY THROUGH SEPTEMBER 2014 (Michael Dawson from Wyeast indicated that this culture may return at some point). Jamie Daly indicated on MTF that he got almost no sourness after 24 hours at 100°F (37.8°C). He lowered the temperature to 90°F-95°F (32.2°C-tolerant35°C) for 36 hours, and as such it can also be used the pH of the wort went down to 3.29. Thus, Jamie recommends 90°F-95°F (32.2°C-35°C) for 60 hours for long-term better souring ; avoid warmer temperatures. He also aerated his starter of L. brevis (2L starter of 1.020 DME) and set it on a stir plate at 95°F <10IBU beersref name="brevis_aeration">[http://www.ncbi.nlm. It also performs well in kettle souringnih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC547135/sour worting where fast Growth Response of Lactobacillus brevis to Aeration and Organic Catalysts. J. R. Stamer and clean lactic acidity is desiredB. O. Stoyla. We recommend pre-acidifying wort to 4 Appl Microbiol.Sep 1967; 15(5 with lactic acid): 1025–1030.]</ref>. The beer wort was not aerated, then pitching and the Lactobacillus blend fermenter was flushed with CO2. These methods need verification. Cell count: 1.0 x 10⁸ (100 million) cells/mL (10 billion cells in a CO2-purged kettle or fermentor at 35-45°C100 mL homebrew pouch) <ref name="wyeast_cellcounts"></ref>.

There is a fair bit of research into hop tolerance out there; its it's not a simple topic as a number of factors come into play to produce hop tolerance. To make things even more complicated, hop tolerance is an inducable inducible trait in many ''Lactobacillus'' species - meaning that a seemingly susceptible strain can become resistant by culturing in ever-increasing doses, and a seemingly resistant strain can become susceptible after a generation or four in a hop-free media.

I've been trying to generate a permanently high-alpha acid resistant lacto strain for a few months now. I've been culturing ''L. brevis '' in escalating IBU wort (starting at 10, currently at 25). Every 4th generation (1 generation = a subculture of a stationary-phase lacto culture, not as in # cell divisions) I pass it through 2 generations of an IBU-free media to try and select for strains which maintain this resistance. This seems to have worked up to ~18 IBU (update: 20-30 IBU), but past that point the resistance appears to remain inducableinducible. I'm hoping a few more generations will provide me with a permanently tolerant strain. Update: I had made a strong (~80ibu) wort that I diluted with unhopped wort. I would grow the ''Lactobacillus'' for a few passages (1 passage = grow culture to completion, then dilute ~1:100 into fresh wort to start next passage) at a set the IBU level, then passage to a wort 3 or so IBU higher. I did 50-60 generations before I got to the high IBU levels (~3 months, 1-2 days per generation). I never did anything to determine how much of that resistance was inheritable <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1421792324515644/?comment_id=1422244054470471&reply_comment_id=1422263561135187&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R6%22%7D Conversation 3 with Bryan of Sui Generis Blog on Milk The Funk regarding Lactobacillus hop tolerance. 09/30/2016.]</ref>.

There are some other options; I've purified (but didn't keep - doh) some pretty resistant strains from grain by by making plates where you half-fill a plate, on an angle, with a high-IBU wort, and then overlay that with a no-IBU wort. This gives you a gradient plate, with low-IBUs on the end where the hopped-wort layer is thinnest and high IBUs where it is thickest. Some of those strains were resistant to over 30IBU, but being early in my yeast farming days I didn't bother keeping those <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1002795743081973/?comment_id=1003625646332316&offset=0&total_comments=16&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D Conversation 1 with Bryan of Sui Generis Blog on Milk The Funk regarding Lactobacillus hop tolerance. 01/19/2015.]</ref>.

Lactobacilli usually don't have these MDT genes 'on', which is why a lot of strains won't do well with hops in the first batch of beer, but over time become more and more tolerant as they increase expression of the MDT's. The overall MDT expression level, in theory, determines the maximum resistance of the bacteria. In the case of my experiments, I'm looking for mutants whose MDT's are permanently stuck 'on' for the resistant strain and 'off' for the sensitive strain <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1143165635711649/?comment_id=1155715074456705&offset=0&total_comments=50&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R0%22%7D Conversation 2 with Bryan of Sui Generis Blog on Milk The Funk regarding Lactobacillus hop tolerance. 09/28/2015.]</ref>.

Hop tolerance is not only species dependent, but is also strain dependent. For example, a dissertation by F.J. Methner measured the pH drop of wort that started at a pH of 5.55 from day 3 to day 14 for several strains of ''L. brevis'' at different IBU levels (7,9,11,13 and 18 IBU's). One strain of ''L. brevis'' eventually got down to a pH of 3.8 at day 14 with 7 IBU's, while another strain got down to 3.3 pH at day 14 (with other strains in-between those numbers). At 18 IBU, the relatively hop intolerant ''L. brevis'' strain got down to only 4.2 pH, while another strain got down to 3.7. In general, the higher the IBU, the slower the pH drop. Interestingly, another species called ''L. coryniformis'' was shown to be more hop tolerant than ''L. brevis''. ''L. coryniformis'' dropped the 18 IBU wort down to 3.6 pH over 14 days <refname="Methner">[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1537381402956735/ Methner, F.D. Uber Die Aromabildung beim berliner weissebier unter besonderer berucksichtigung von sauren and estern (data reported and translated by Benedikt Rausch on Milk THe Funk Facebook group). 1987.]</ref>.  Methner's data is shown below; graphs created by Benedikt Rausch <ref name="Methner" />. Y axis = pH, X axis = days. <gallery>File:Methner 7IBU.JPG|'''7 IBU''' File:Methner 9IBU.JPG|'''9 IBU''' File:Methner 11IBU.JPG|'''11 IBU''' File:Methner 13IBU.JPG|'''13 IBU''' File:Methner 18IBU.JPG|'''18 IBU''' </gallery>::'''L70''': ''L. coryniformis''::'''L14, L18, L22, L29, L88, L92''': ''L. Brevis''

* [[Hops#Antimicrobial_Properties|Hops antimicrobial propertiesAntimicrobial Properties]] and [[Hops#Dry_Hopping|Dry Hopping Inhibits ''Lactobacillus'']].