13,592
edits
Changes
m
no edit summary
A native wild-microbe fermentation may also be achieved by ambiently inoculating small amounts of wort and growing up caught microbes to check for suitability. This process has often been called a "spontaneous starter" and is common in homebrew production <ref> [http://www.themadfermentationist.com/2011/04/ambient-spontaneous-yeast-starters.html The Mad Fermentationist Spontaneous Starters, accessed 7-May-2015]</ref>, however, it is arguably more accurately described as one of the few methods of [http://www.milkthefunk.com/wiki/Wild_Yeast_Isolation bioprospecting]. Bioprospecting from ambient collection allows for the screening of the microbes to remove wild cultures with aggressive off-flavors and/or mold. This is not unlike the potential of used oak barrels, where well-performing barrels may be kept and used to ferment subsequent batches (where the organisms residing in the barrel can exert their influence on the batch) while poorly performing barrels may be discarded and removed from the brewery. This process does differ from oak barrels in that native microbes are cultured and pitched into the wort, rather than the additional inoculation being a result of porous surfaces that have not been fully sanitized. As different microbes survive and thrive in different environments, barrels or pre-screened and grown starters will probably not provide a complete profile of the microbes present in traditional spontaneous fermentation beers. However, a combination of a coolship to inoculate the wort with ambient/brewhouse resident microbes combined with a form of pre-screening such as barrel re-use and/or spontaneous starters may provide the full microbiota present in traditional spontaneously fermented products.
There is some debate as to whether using spontaneous starters should still be termed "spontaneous fermentation" <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1225800400781505/ MTF Facebook thread about naming]</ref>. Each brewer will have to decide for him or herself what terms to use. We recommend transparency and clarity in descriptions and process to avoid potential confusion. In a stricter sense, beers using active inoculation with spontaneous starters might better be described with terms like 'wild beer', 'beer fermented with native microbes', or a description of the spontaneous starter process rather than entirely "spontaneous beers". Especially if the full wort volume was not ambiently cooled and the starter was allowed to grow for some time before mixing it in. An alternative term for the process itself includes something like "ambient bioprospecting". See [[Spontaneous_Fermentation#Alternative_Applications_of_Spontaneous_Fermentation|alternative applications of spontaneous fermentation]] below. Beers receiving additions of isolated cultures or bottle dregs are not spontaneous and are discussed under [[Mixed Fermentation|mixed-culture fermentation]] and [[Commercial_Sour_Beer_Inoculation|commercial sour beer inoculation]]. Ambient bioprospecting 9or (or "spontaneous starters") are discussed in more detail on the [[Wild_Yeast_Isolation#Catching|Wild Yeast Isolation]] page.
It has been suggested by some that the terminology of "spontaneous fermentation" is not precise enough for describing the process. Other phrases such as "open-air inoculation", "non-selected fermentation", "ambient inoculation", "coolship ales", and "wild ales" are phrases that some people suggest for alternative nomenclature for spontaneously fermented beer. However, the phrase "spontaneous fermentation" has been widely used by the Belgian lambic brewers to designate this process and the term has been applied in the [https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A52016XC0514%2804%29 EU's TSG law for lambic]. This term has also been widely adopted by the American brewing industry to the point where many brewers and consumers alike recognize the meaning of the phrase "spontaneous fermentation" <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/2056705564357647/?comment_id=2057416344286569&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D Various MTF members. Milk The Funk Facebook group thread on the wording of 'spontaneous fermentation'. 04/12/2018.]</ref>.